Email Marketing Underperforming? Let’s Troubleshoot It

While no one has claimed email marketing is dying for many, many years, some marketers have become increasingly concerned with performance declines, despite the channel generating returns on investment that are often at least twice as high as most other channels. If your organization is concerned about your email marketing performance, here are some of the root causes we’ve been seeing with our clients that go beyond the usual economic or competitive pressures.

>> Read the entire article on CMSWire.com

2026 Q1 Marketing Benchmark report

Zeta Global’s latest Marketing Benchmark report shares aggregated data on SMS click rates and on email sends, open rates, click rates, click-to-open rates, and unsubscribe rates from Jan. 1 through Mar. 31, 2026, including year-over-year changes. The email benchmarks are broken down by industry (e.g., retail; travel, hospitality & entertainment; financial services & insurance; and media) and by email type (e.g., promotional and triggered).

The report also includes:

  • Commentary and context from our digital marketing experts so you can understand performance changes
  • Tips on how to use benchmarks effectively
  • Discussions of the latest inbox provider changes from Gmail and Yahoo Mail and how they affect marketers

To get the report via a free, no-form download…

>> Visit Zeta Global’s Resource Center

The Last Word on March 2026

The Last Word

A roundup of digital marketing and email marketing articles, posts, and social buzz you might have missed last month…

Must-read articles, posts & reports

The AI-Search Adoption Survey: 6 Charts Show Where (and How) People Search (Digital Marketing Tips

First Take on The Forrester Wave Email Marketing Service Providers 2026 (Email Vendor Selection)

6 Post-Purchase Moments that Shape Customer Lifetime Value (Holistic Email Academy)

Amazon Wins Court Order to Block Perplexity’s AI Shopping Agent (CNBC)

What’s an ‘E-shaped’ Economy — and Where Do You Fit in It? (MarketWatch)

This Is What Work Looks Like in a (Not So) Future World (VKTR)

Interactive Emails: Pros and Cons, Tips & Examples [2026] (Moosend)

Insightful & entertaining social posts

Noteworthy subject lines

Really Good Emails, 3/17 – You’ve earned 12 fake points and our respect
Goldbelly, 3/19 – Peep This 💐🐇🐣 Top Easter Eats
Williams Sonoma, 3/26 – Sweet details for a joyful Easter 🐰🌸
Michaels, 3/31 – We’ve got it: NEW! PEEPS x Hello Kitty and Friends Easter collection 🐤 🎉
Nintendo, 3/10 – Happy MAR10 Day!
Burlington, 3/6 – Happy National Dress Day!
Goldbelly, 3/13 – Pi Day Pie Sale ENDS TOMORROW! 🥧
IKEA Family, 3/9 – Lost an hour 🥱? Gain big savings on sleep essentials 🛏️!
NFLShop.com, 3/20 – Perfect Layers For Changing Weather 🌿
Wayfair 3/15 – Your vertical garden need-to-knows 👉
Overstock, 3/12 – Make your patio pop ✨
West Elm, 3/26 – A functional entryway
IKEA Family, 3/2 – Sofa savings you’ll want to sit down for 🛋️
IKEA Family, 3/22 – Water-saving tips your wallet will soak up
Allrecipes Tonight, 3/12 – The Only Hot Dogs You Should Buy
Priceline, 3/9 – Hack #3: These filters = savings!
Chubbies After Party, 3/26 – Introducing Chubbies AFTERPARTY
adidas CONFIRMED, 3/22 – The wolf awakens
Duluth | Underwear Sale, 3/30 – ALL. UNDERWEAR. ON. SALE.
Home Depot, 3/25 – FIFA World Cup 2026™ 🏆Experience It IRL
PINK, 3/19 – NEW Desert Looks Loading 🌵🤠🎶
Urban Outfitters, 3/19 – BAGGU + UO 🍒 Cherry Land Collection
adidas, 3/15 – Explore the new Bob Marley collection
Quiksilver, 3/10 – New Collab Alert
Nitya from Lonely Planet, 3/10 – You’re invited: Become a Founding App Member!

New posts on EmailMarketingRules.com

What Makes Enterprise Email Marketing Different

Less Copy, More Clicks: 9 Proven Ways to Improve Marketing Message Performance

How Marketers Can Adapt to Gmail’s ‘Manage Subscriptions’

Litmus Live: Omnichannel Subscribers + Email Accessibility Mistakes

How Ethical Are Your Digital Marketing Tactics?

Don’t Discount These Four Trends Driving Innovation in Restaurant & Hospitality

3-Year Anniversary of the 4th Edition of ‘Email Marketing Rules’

The Last Word on February 2026

2026 Digital Marketing Lookbook

2026 Digital Marketing Lookbook

Zeta Global’s third annual Lookbook chronicles the latest design trends and spotlights 20 standout campaigns from among the tens of thousands our Creative Services team reads each year.

For each featured campaign, we point out all the ways they’re innovating and worth emulating, whether it’s in terms of design, development, copywriting, strategy, or omnichannel orchestration. And because great marketing is never finished, we also highlight opportunities for each campaign from both our Creative Services team and Athena, Zeta’s superintelligent agent.

Along the way, you’ll see clear trends emerge, such as the power of:

  • Clear messaging and easy-to-follow layouts
  • Visually led storytelling, where imagery takes the lead driving clarity and engagement
  • Engaging content, including polls and non-promotional content
  • Organic, human-centered visual design that builds authenticity
  • Social proof that validates the brand’s community
  • Cross-channel coordination of messaging
  • Real-time automation aligned to subscriber behavior

We invite you to explore these campaigns on your own or, even better, with your digital marketing team. As you do, consider not just what inspires you, but what you can test, scale, and operationalize to elevate your own customer experience in 2026.

>> Get inspired

In Defense of Mother’s Day Opt-Outs (and Empathy in Marketing)

Being empathetic is hard. If it were easy, then every brand would do it. Because it takes time and effort, that often means getting approval from your boss, who may not see the ROI in catering to the sensitivities of sometimes relatively small segments of customers.

A great case in point is Mother’s Day opt-outs, where brands give their subscribers the opportunity to be suppressed from receiving Mother’s Day promotions. Here’s a dramatization of how you might respond to your boss if they’re not seeing the value in providing this option.

>> Read the full article on CMSWire.com

What Makes Enterprise Email Marketing Different

Enterprise email marketing and SMB email marketing use the same protocols, the same inbox providers, the same basic formats. But the operational reality behind them is so different that organizations scaling from mid-market to enterprise often discover their tools, processes, and team structures need to be rebuilt from the foundation up.

This post by Knak dives into the critical elements that allow SMB email programs to grow to enterprise scale, covering:

  • Signs you’ve outgrown your email marketing tools
  • Brand governance and speed in enterprise email
  • Why email creation is the enterprise bottleneck
  • Proportional governance for enterprise email programs
  • Measuring business outcomes, not campaign metrics

>> Read the entire post on Knak.com

Less Copy, More Clicks: 9 Proven Ways to Improve Marketing Message Performance

Attention is scarce. Performance is everything.

Marketers invest heavily in identity resolution, predictive intelligence, and real-time activation to reach the right consumers. But even the most sophisticated targeting can underperform if the message itself creates friction.

In permission-based channels like email, SMS, RCS, and push, you have already earned access. The subscriber opted in. The real challenge is not breaking through the noise, but converting attention into action. That requires discipline.

Concise, value-driven messaging consistently outperforms bloated creative because it respects time, sharpens intent, and drives faster decisions. In our client’s campaigns across retail, financial services, and travel, Zeta’s Creative Studio team repeatedly sees that clarity increases click-through rates, reduces drop-off, and improves downstream conversion.

When real-time signals identify high-intent prospects, brevity becomes a force multiplier.

Here are nine practical ways to craft promotional messages that convert.

>> Read the entire post in Zeta’s Resource Center

Gmail Manage Subscriptions Inadvertently Increasing Total Unsubscribe Rates

“Received too many emails” has perennially been one of the top reasons consumers unsubscribe. Google is clearly trying to address this complaint with the “Manage Subscriptions” functionality it launched in Gmail last year and rolled out over the course of subsequent months. However, the functionality is hampered by flaws that limit its usefulness for consumers, while at the same time arbitrarily punishing some marketers.

>> Read the entire post in Zeta’s Resource Center

Watch 'Omnichannel Subscribers' on-demand on YouTube

If you missed Litmus Live, now is your chance to watch all the sessions on-demand on YouTube. Those include my session on managing omnichannel subscribers better, and a session on email accessibility mistakes by my colleague Tylor Loposser and former colleague Lauren Castady.

>> Watch ‘Omnichannel Subscriber’ session

>> Watch ‘Email Accessibility Mistakes’ session

How Ethical Are Your Digital Marketing Tactics

The issue of ethics in digital marketing is being supercharged by advancements in data management, machine learning, generative AI, and AI agents. In particular, that last one is ringing alarm bells for brands. According to an EMarketer survey, 71% of national brands say that marketers need to establish ethical and privacy standards for agent-led recommendations and purchases.

Looking more broadly, the core questions brands are asking themselves is:

Just because we can do something, does that mean we should? And if we should, how can we do it safely and ethically?

To spark internal conversations and help brands get alignment across their marketing teams, below are a bunch of statements about potential marketing tactics. Many involve AI, but not all. Rate the statements yourself, then have your teams rate them. Use those to identify the points of divergence. Foster conversations around those issues to get everyone on the same page and to refine your AI strategies.

It’s worth emphasizing that the list includes tactics that may run afoul of the law. While mitigating legal risk should absolutely be a goal of any brand, finding your brand’s ethical compass and building consensus around that is the primary intent of this exercise.

>> Read the entire article on CMSWire.com